With raving reviews from any number of
food magazines,
blogs, and
guide books, we still don't know why it took us so long to make it to a restaurant located about 500 yards from our apartment. Worse, we pass it four times a day on our way to and from
the park with Panda. Worst, its founder is one of the co-founders of a neighborhood favorite,
Le Baratin. What is wrong with us???
So what's our excuse for avoiding Le Chapeau Melon? Certainly we can't blame the charming exterior and cozy interior, nor the wine bar/table d'hôte concept we love so much. (They carry only organic wines. Highly-regarded organic wines. Too bad we still know next-to-nothing about wine.)
Clearly we have no excuse. Especially since this place makes us look more attractive than any other restaurant we've been to this year. But I digress.
Here's how the menu works: Wednesdays and Sundays, you can order à la carte from a smallish but excellent menu. All other nights that the restaurant's open, they offer a fixed four-course meal for €32.50, with cheese and/or dessert another €6. One slightly weird thing is that they charge a €8.50 "corking fee" if you buy a bottle of wine with your meal. (On the other hand, if you patronize Le Chapeau Melon as a wine store rather than a restaurant, you're charged no such fee.) But they have some sub-€10 wines, so even if you're watching your wallet, the cost isn't prohibitive.
On to the food. The night we were there, the
menu included green apple over hearts of salmon in a soy sauce and olive oil base;
vitello tonnato, which is cold, thinly sliced veal under a mayonnaise and tuna sauce; cream of mussel and saffron; and
cannette rouennaise with celery purée, carrots à l'orange, and sautéed asparagus. They certainly get points for quantity and diversity of protein, and for some creative pairings.
The salmon/green apple dish was fantastic. Sweet and savory competed for attention with every bite. Plus, just look at the presentation: this is dynamic, even architecturally inspired food. 10 points, Le Chapeau Melon.
Annnnd we're taking those 10 points away. Seriously, no amount of photo editing can mask the sheer ugliness of this presentation. Even the (possibly unintentional?) happy face formed by those capers and that olive oil only made the veal look like it might just be trying to eat us. Plus, while it didn't taste bad, we wonder whether
vitello tonnato might be an acquired taste.
Ok, that's a little better. And clearly my food photography is to blame for at least part of the unsightliness of this food. But imagine the great leap in beauty that could be accomplished just be throwing a sprig of something green and fresh on top of that saffron-y, creamy concoction. Also, it was a little salty. But mussels are always awesome, and I sopped up the last of this soup like it was my job.
And the restaurant gets its 10 points back with the final dish. Just like the first dish, we have all kinds of colors, textures, and tastes. The celery purée was delightful (we can't wait to get back to our food processor so we can try this at home) and the carrot
à l'orange showed just how clever the chef could be. Cannette rouennaise indicates that we were served young female duck that had been raised in Normandy (see also
canard de rouen). Considering the rather small portion, it might have been nice to have something a little less fatty (that whole bottom layer was basically inedible), but the meat was cooked just right, and for once there was no sauce to mask the taste of meat - instead, we could choose whether to combine the duck with one (or several) of the vegetables for each bite.
So there you have it: mixed results that fly in the face of all that hype. Considering the price (and the fact that the menu doesn't include dessert - what were they thinking!!??) we'll probably go back to passing this place on our way to
Kiwizine, which is right next door, and rightfully still our favorite restaurant in Belleville.